Council 4191 Past Grand Knights
- Jere Cassidy – 2020-2022
Matt Auker – 2018-2020 - Ben Hoover – 2016-2018
- Brian Heisler – 2014-2016
- Bill Hydock – 2012-2014
- Mark Hartman – 2010-2012
- Dan Dacey – 2008-2010
- Scott Harper – 2006-2008
- Greg Schlotterer – 2004-2006
- Joe Lerman – 2002-2004
- John Palm – 2000-2002
- Joe Kurpiel – 1998-2000
- Joe Batisti – 1997-1998
- Mark Janke – 1994-1997
- Dave Hugenbruch – 1992-1994
- Jim Smith – 1991-1992
- Dick Bernhardt – 1990-1991
- Ron Kreider – 1989-1990
- Dennis Floyd – 1987-1989
- Ron Kreider – 1986-1987
- Dave Huff # – 1984-1986
- Mike Deetz – 1982-1984
- John McDonald # – 1981-1982
- Joe Klazas – 1980-1981
- Alden Metcalfe # – 1979-1980
- Andrew Marvin # – 1978-1979
- Ken Stauffer – 1977-1978
- Dave Rufe # – 1976-1977
- George McDermmit – 1975-1976
- Joseph Windish # – 1966-1967
- Nathan Buffenmeyer # – 1964-1966
- Harold Staab # – 1963-1964
- John Flora # – 1961-1963
- Edward Iwanoski # – 1960-1961
- Peter Sturla # – 1959-1960
- George Martin # – 1958-1959
- Andy Kuzmiak # – 1957-1958
- John Deller # – 1956-1957
Those marked with a # have passed on to their Heavenly Reward.